menu
Car accidents can change lives in an instant. But from a legal perspective, the real story of an accident is pieced together over weeks and months through careful investigation. In Georgia, a car accident claim is not just about showing that a crash occurred—it’s about proving how it happened, who was responsible, and how the injuries impact the injured party’s life both now and in the future.
At Kevin Patrick Law, we’ve seen firsthand how a thorough and precise investigation can mean the difference between a denied claim and a successful settlement or verdict. Insurance companies conduct their own investigations designed to minimize payouts. That’s why injured people need a strong advocate who understands both the facts on the ground and the rules of evidence inside the courtroom.
This article takes you step-by-step through how a car accident investigation unfolds in Georgia and why these details matter so much for your case.
Georgia operates under a fault-based insurance system, which means the party responsible for causing the accident (and their insurer) can be held liable for damages. But establishing fault is rarely straightforward.
For example, police reports may include diagrams and officer impressions, but they are not conclusive proof in court. Witness memories fade, skid marks disappear, and vehicles get repaired quickly. Meanwhile, defense attorneys and insurers may argue that injuries pre-existed the crash or that another party is to blame.
A meticulous, attorney-driven investigation is therefore essential to:
Establish liability under O.C.G.A. § 51-1-6 (duty and breach of duty).
Document damages as required under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-4 (personal injury damages).
Identify all potential defendants to maximize available insurance coverage.
Ensure that key evidence is admissible and persuasive before a judge or jury.
The Georgia Uniform Motor Vehicle Accident Report is often the starting point. It contains the officer’s initial observations, party information, and contributing factors like following too closely, failure to yield, or suspected impairment.
While useful, these reports are not admissible as substantive evidence in most civil cases because they are considered hearsay under Georgia law. However, they provide leads that can be followed up with admissible testimony and physical evidence.
At Kevin Patrick Law, we don’t stop at the crash report. Instead, we:
Cross-check it with photographs and videos from the scene.
Verify that all witnesses listed were actually contacted and interviewed.
Look for inconsistencies or missing information that may become important later.
Georgia courts give significant weight to physical evidence because it speaks louder than subjective memory. Our firm acts quickly to preserve:
Vehicle damage and black box data: Many modern cars contain event data recorders (EDRs) that capture speed, braking, and airbag deployment. Under spoliation principles in Georgia law, failing to preserve this evidence can result in sanctions.
Scene evidence: Skid marks, debris fields, and roadway conditions can support accident reconstruction.
Video surveillance: We routinely send preservation letters to nearby businesses and request dashcam footage from parties or law enforcement.
In serious cases, we bring in accident reconstructionists who apply engineering principles to determine vehicle speeds, points of impact, and driver visibility. Their testimony is admissible under Georgia’s expert witness rule (O.C.G.A. § 24-7-702) if it is based on sufficient facts and reliable methods.
Witness testimony can be powerful—but only if it is carefully gathered and preserved. In Georgia, credibility is key. Inconsistent or vague witness testimony can harm a case as much as it helps.
We approach witness interviews with a trial mindset:
Locking in testimony early: Witness memories degrade quickly. We take detailed statements soon after the accident and may use affidavits or depositions to preserve them for trial.
Cross-checking accounts: We compare witness observations with physical evidence. If someone recalls that a driver was speeding, we match that with skid mark length or black box data.
Uncovering bias: Georgia juries are attentive to credibility. If a witness has ties to the defendant, that must be disclosed and addressed.
Insurance companies frequently argue that injuries are unrelated to the accident or are less severe than claimed. That’s why linking injuries to the crash through medical records and testimony is a cornerstone of any investigation.
Kevin Patrick Law thoroughly reviews:
Emergency medical services (EMS) and hospital records.
Imaging results such as MRIs, CT scans, and X-rays.
Specialist and rehabilitation notes.
Future medical treatment projections.
In court, causation must be proven to a reasonable degree of medical certainty. We often work with treating physicians and independent medical experts to establish that the injuries were directly caused by the accident—a requirement under Georgia case law.
One of the most technical aspects of a car accident investigation is ensuring that all responsible parties are identified. Georgia follows a modified comparative negligence system under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33, which means:
A plaintiff can recover damages if they are less than 50% at fault.
Damages are reduced by the plaintiff’s percentage of fault.
This makes it critical to properly assign fault percentages and pursue claims against all liable entities, which may include:
Negligent drivers who violated traffic laws.
Employers under respondeat superior if the driver was acting in the scope of employment.
Bars or restaurants under Georgia’s dram shop law (O.C.G.A. § 51-1-40) if they served alcohol to a visibly intoxicated person who later caused the crash.
Vehicle manufacturers if a defect, such as brake failure, contributed to the accident.
Failure to include a responsible party can limit recovery, particularly if the primary defendant has insufficient insurance coverage.
Expert testimony often transforms a case from speculative to compelling. At Kevin Patrick Law, we regularly consult with:
Accident reconstruction experts to visually demonstrate how the crash occurred.
Human factors experts to explain driver perception, reaction time, and visibility.
Medical experts to testify about long-term disability, need for future care, and pain management.
Economic experts to calculate lost earning capacity, benefits, and life-care costs.
Under Georgia evidence rules, the admissibility of expert testimony hinges on reliability and relevance. By carefully selecting and preparing experts, we ensure that their opinions withstand Daubert-type challenges raised by opposing counsel.
Insurance companies in Georgia frequently raise defenses such as:
Comparative fault (arguing the injured person was also negligent).
Sudden emergency doctrine (the defendant reacted reasonably to an unexpected hazard).
Pre-existing conditions (the injuries existed before the accident).
Failure to mitigate damages (the plaintiff did not follow medical advice or delayed treatment).
A detailed investigation allows us to anticipate and counter these defenses with evidence. For example, we may use medical records to distinguish new injuries from pre-existing ones or use black box data to disprove sudden emergency claims.
Even though most car accident cases settle, we prepare every case as though it is headed to trial. Georgia juries are attentive to detail, and preparation demonstrates strength in negotiations.
This includes:
Developing demonstrative exhibits such as accident reconstructions, medical illustrations, and day-in-the-life videos.
Lining up lay witnesses (family, friends, co-workers) to testify about the impact of the injuries.
Ensuring compliance with O.C.G.A. Title 9, Chapter 11 (Georgia Civil Practice Act) regarding discovery and evidence disclosures.
A case that is trial-ready often leads to stronger settlements because insurers recognize the risk of facing a well-prepared plaintiff’s case in court.
Investigating a car accident in Georgia is both a science and an art. It requires technical knowledge of accident reconstruction, medical causation, and Georgia’s evidence rules, combined with strategic thinking about how a jury will perceive the facts.
At Kevin Patrick Law, we pride ourselves on leaving no stone unturned in accident investigations. From the crash scene to the courtroom, we are committed to uncovering the truth and securing justice for our clients.
If you or a loved one has been injured in a Georgia car accident, don’t wait—evidence disappears quickly, and insurance companies are already working against you. Contact us today for a free consultation and let our experience in complex accident investigations work for you.
Get Your Free Consultation Today
required fields *